Remake This! Legend (1985)

There are no new ideas.  Or at least that’s how it seems, considering Hollywood’s penchant for remaking every movie ever made.  But before we have to endure the 83rd version of The Amazing Spider-man (no offense, Andrew Garfield) or a shoot-’em-up Casablanca 2012: Mayan Apocalypse, I would like to suggest that Hollywood look into their Great Big Book of Fail and remake something that could benefit from a re-imagining, or two.


Disclaimer: management takes no responsibility toward factual or mythological accuracy.

Legend is just such a movie.  A recent bout of insomnia found me flipping channels at some obscene hour of the morning and quite frankly, I’d almost forgotten about this festering turd of a film.  Almost.  To sum up:  Legend is a 1985 action-fantasy film directed by Ridley Scott, who is normally a very good director but has his moments of utter failure.  Hannibal comes to mind.  Recent movie-goers, think Prometheus.  Tom Cruise–who I couldn’t stand before not being able to stand him was cool–plays Jack, a noble-hearted child of the forest, who speaks to the animals and runs about wearing an ersatz-leaf tunic and way too much body glitter.

Did you think I was kidding about the glitter?
Photo taken from; click to go to the page.

Mia Sara plays Lili, Jack’s love interest, a virginal princess whose purity almost brings about the undoing of the world.  How?  It’s because she is so supremely untainted that the unicorns (unicorns??!?) stop and allow her to pet them, which in turns allows the goblin Blix to shoot one with a poison arrow, steal its horn, and take it back to the underworld and the Lord of Darkness, who ultimately wants to turn the world to an eternal frozen night.

Three things.

1) Unicorns?  Really?  Reallllllly?  Oh, Ridley Scott, you put those things back on the walls of every white 9-year-old girl in America right this instant!  Unless those unicorns are secretly replicants, I can’t figure out what in the hell you’re doing with them.

2) Can we talk for just a second about the alarming, demented, unbelievably unfair gender messaging surrounding Lili?  She’s virtuous, and by her virtue nearly ushered in the end of the world.  If she and Jack had just bumped uglies once she wouldn’t have been so attractive to the unicorns and wouldn’t have unwittingly played into evil’s hands, but then she would have been slutty and bad by default.  In this movie, a woman can’t win for losing.

3) This Blix:

Photo from

Admittedly, a pretty good goblin.

Not this Blix:

Just for clarification.


What else?  The script was wooden and the story was hokey and contrived, alternately trying to be a serious adventure saga amidst doubling back on itself to insert poorly-developed moments of “comic relief”.  It felt like bumbling dwarves and weird gravelly-voiced elves wandered in from the set of Labyrinth and did what they could until they found their way back to their original roles.  The characters, for the most part, are unidimensional and completely uninteresting.  Regarding Tom Cruise, his character is both uninteresting AND miscast.  So why on earth would I want to see more of it?

Because Tim Curry, as the Lord of Darkness, is fantastic.

He is also, sadly, on the screen the least of all the principle actors.  Or maybe I was just aching for him to be on screen again and do something with this stinkbomb of a movie, but it seems like even though he is the main antagonist, he is hardly present until the end.  I understand those ginormous horns had to be tough to hold up but still, it is a shame; even the un-fluid and deadly-flat script sounded lyrical in Tim Curry’s capable hands.

So here’s how I would propose to remake Legend.  First, get Tim Curry to agree to reprise his role as Darkness because without him, this movie has NO. THING.  Going for it.  Second, jettison any and all references to Jack, Lili, Tom Cruise, Mia Sara, or bumbling and ineffective dwarves.  You can keep Blix because really, he did look pretty cool.  Third, assemble a screenwriting team of William Monahan, who wrote The Departed, among other things, and David Benioff and D. B. Weiss from Game of Thrones.  Mesh these talents together and reinvent Legend as one ass-kicking biopic.

That’s right.  A biopic, that explores Darkness’s rebellious nature (helloooo?  He’s got to have one) which culminates in his accepting the mantle of Darkness.  Maybe he tries to be a hippie and weaves garlands of flowers for his hair.  Maybe he tries to go straight and opens his own butcher shop, but can’t stop killing his customers.  Or, include Lili in a revamped “he’s taken her to his dark domain” storyline, and have Darkness finally learn to trust, only to be betrayed by the woman he loves because why not?  She won’t look any worse off than she does in the original movie.  The point is, he’s a great character and whatever someone comes up with is bound to be a thousand times better than the original miasmic bubo of a film.

Hollywood, I’m looking forward to hearing from you.

In the meantime, please enjoy some Tim Curry.

6 responses to Remake This! Legend (1985)

  1. Terri, you have me thinking of you whenever I find myself in the midst of a stinker. Howz that for a compliment? I caught the 1964 My Fair Lady (Audrey Hepburn and Rex Harrison) musical film over Thanksgiving and sat dumb founded at how offensive it was. The costumes were the highlight. And maybe Stanley Holloway’s song and dance snippets. It’s sorta comforting that in a relatively short span of 48 yrs or 27 with Legend that women’s roles have evolved? They have evolved, haven’t they? -Nikki


    • beyondpaisley – Author

      Ooh, haven’t watched MFL in about a hundred years, though I can certainly pinpoint at least one or two offensive moments from memory. That whole “Why Can’t A Woman Be More Like A Man” song leaps to mind. I should give it a look again. And of course I’m honored that I inspire stinker-thought! LOL Agree about the costumes. Not entirely sure about women’s least, there’s more room for discomfort than I would like.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s